“Why do bad things happen to good people?” is a question that has been asked through the ages. We have no trouble with the idea of good things happening to good people. We have no trouble with the idea of bad things happening to bad people. That all just makes sense. It fits with our idea of fundamental justice. When you consider that being a good and virtuous person takes work and discipline it makes sense that the world would reward such things. In the Hindu religion it all fits into the idea of karma.
But when you are a good person and bad things happen to you the fundamental operation of the world seems to have gone wrong. We may be able to shrug off some of it. Sometimes things just happen. But when it is something major, like a debilitating injury to an innocent bystander, or a horrible medical diagnosis to a person who has always made healthy choices, -especially if it is us- then we are challenged to the core. I’ve heard people say many times that they can’t believe in a god that would let such things happen. I can sympathize with their struggles. But that sympathy is not biblical.
People have sometimes answered the question of why bad things happen to good people by saying that we have freedom. If a bad people exercise their freedom wrongly then innocent people get hurt. There is logic to that. There can’t truly be freedom if the possibility of hurting innocent people isn’t an option. But that does not explain why natural disasters and random happenstance happen to both the good and to the bad. And, why things sometimes go bad despite our best efforts.
We’ll turn to what Jesus says in a moment, but we should note that the Old Testament’s thoughts on good and bad fit with our basic understanding of justice. Deuteronomy 28-30 teaches that if people are faithful to God and do what is good and right God will cause them to prosper. And if they lose faith and do what is wrong God will punish them. Ezekiel 18:26-27 warns, “When the righteous turn away from their righteousness and commit iniquity, they shall die for it… Again, when the wicked turn away from the wickedness they have committed and do what is lawful and right, they shall save their life.”
It was also commonly believed among Jews in Jesus’ day that sin brought punishment. In John 9 the disciples see a man who has been blind from birth and they ask Jesus, “Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?” It is in Jesus’ reply that we start to see how his teachings differ entirely. He replies, “Neither this man nor his parents sinned; but that God’s works might be revealed in him.” That is a very odd response. It doesn’t really answer the question, but I think we’re okay with it. What we are not okay with is what Jesus said in today’s gospel reading.
The text started off, “At that very time there were some present who told him about the Galileans whose blood Pilate had mingled with their sacrifices.” (Luke 13:1) That needs a bit of explanation. What it means is that some Jews from Galilee had been killed while they were worshipping. It happened at the order of Roman governor, Pontus Pilate. Pilate was known for brutality and disdaining Jewish religious practices. What Jesus is being asked is if those Jews who were killed during worship were somehow particularly heinous that God used Pilate to kill them. Perhaps think of it in terms of God sending a lightning bolt to kill a particularly evil person in their act of evil.
Jesus replies, “Do you think that because these Galileans suffered in this way they were worse sinners than all other Galileans? No, I tell you.”
Okay, our interest is peaked. They were not somehow worse sinners. So then what is the reason? Jesus continues with a gut punch, “No, I tell you; but unless you repent, you will all perish as they did.”
Ouch. Why do bad things happen to good people? Jesus basically just said that all people are bad.
You may remember from last week that we talked about the way Jesus had harsh teachings for the Pharisees and the lawyers. They were people who were prominent and of means. Then Jesus also had harsh teachings for the crowds. The crowds certainly contained many people who were poor and struggling. Jesus even called these poor struggling people hypocrites; just like he called the Pharisees and lawyers hypocrites. What was going on? Why not have a word of comfort for these people?
That takes us to what we read today. And here again, Jesus is calling all people sinners. I suppose if you ask Jesus, “Why do bad things happen to good people?” Jesus just might reply, “There’s no such thing as good people.” We don’t like to hear that!
Jesus goes on in the gospel, “Or those eighteen who were killed when the tower of Siloam fell on them – do you think that they were worse offenders than all the others living in Jerusalem?” This tower of Siloam was presumably part of the defenses of Jerusalem that collapsed unexpectedly. So, did God arrange things such that it fell so as to punish particularly bad people? Jesus goes on, “No, I tell you; but unless you repent, you will all perish just as they did.”
Again, these are not nice teachings! When we feel we are wrongfully suffering we want to feel some compassion from God. We certainly don’t want to be further condemned!
The scene, and the whole series of scenes we’ve been reading these last several weeks, wraps up with the parable of the fig tree. The owner of a vineyard has an unproductive fig tree in it. It may seem odd to have a fig tree in a vineyard. I’ve heard two completely contradictory theories on this. Some say that it would have been very strange to have a fig tree in a vineyard. Others say it wouldn’t have been odd at all. I don’t really know. Personally, I suspect Jesus is deliberately mixing images. The Old Testament prophets often compared the nation to a vineyard. They also compared the nation to a fig tree. But I don’t think there were fig orchards. So, it wouldn’t make sense to talk about a fig tree not bearing fruit among others. At the same time it wouldn’t make sense to remove an unproductive vine in a vineyard because it’s hard to isolate and remove an individual vine. I think Jesus is mixing both images deliberately.
Whatever the case, the owner of the fig tree notes that the tree is not bearing fruit. It hasn’t borne fruit for three years. That doesn’t mean it’s a three-year-old tree. Fig trees weren’t expected to bear for a least the first ten years. That means this is a thirteen-year-old tree. For thirteen years it has taken up space and given nothing in return. It makes sense that the owner commands the gardener to rip it out. It should be replaced with something that will be productive. But the gardener begs for mercy for the tree. The gardener asks that it be given extra care and attention for one more year. Then if it doesn’t produce it can be ripped out.
This parable defies concise interpretation. Most of Jesus’ parables can have multiple meanings. We could spend an hour spinning it out in any number of directions. But all of them get to the same point, which is both comforting and challenging.
First, let’s remember what we’ve learned from the things we’ve read from Jesus over the last several weeks. They boil down to the idea that we are all sinners in need of God’s grace. None of us can claim to be virtuous on our own. Recognizing that we are sinners is not to depress us, but it is to push us to recognize our need for God for everything.
Then we come to today. Why do bad things happen to good people? We’re asking the wrong question. We’re all sinners in need of God’s grace and we all deserve punishment. However, by God’s grace we are given another chance. And we are not just given another chance, but by God’s grace God will continue to care for us and nurture us. God will nurture us into loving productivity. That’s the good and wonderful news. But there is another “however”.
However, this is all happening by God’s mercy for us; sinners that we are. If we become complacent or boastful or think we deserve God’s love, then we are continuing to be like an unproductive fig tree. God always reserves the right to rip us out and get rid of us. You’ve heard the phrase, “We are to love and fear God.” That’s simply recognizing God’s sovereignty. God can do as God wants to do. God has made us promises, and by so doing God has voluntarily put limits upon God’s own power. But God is not to be mocked. Ultimate punishment is always God’s right.
So, why do bad things happen to good people? It is a question that has been asked many times and will be asked many times again. But according to Jesus it misses the point. Whatever our life’s circumstances, we rely on God’s grace. We remember that whether life is good or bad, easy or hard, God is working on us to make us good and productive. Learn and grow through adversity for that also is the grace of God.
No comments:
Post a Comment