Tuesday, April 21, 2020

April 19, 2020 Easter 2 Matthew 28:11-15


The gospel reading today is five short verses but it is packed with significant details and it gets at some of the most fundamental questions of faith.  It’s all about contrasts.
The first contrast is between the women and the guards.  You’ll remember that these guards are Roman guards the Jewish leaders asked the Roman governor Pilate to have.  They said they wanted to have the tomb of Jesus guarded so that his body wouldn’t be stolen.
The idea is absurd – guarding a dead guy’s tomb.  Of course in America we have the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier but the guard is of course simply honorary.  Biblical scholars tell us there isn’t historical reality behind the presence of the guard at Jesus tomb.  And indeed the other gospels do not report it.  That means my speculation is pointless, but still, I wonder how I’d feel if I was asked to guard the grave of just some country guy who had been executed; so that his body isn’t stolen by his followers… who were so cowardly they fled at his arrest!  This guard duty is insulting!  But I digress.
We aren’t told how many guards there are, but it is several big burly guys with the might of Rome to back them up.  Then there are two women – Mary Magdalene and “the other Mary.”  (Now that’s a way to get in the Bible – being “the other” Mary.
We have two women, women who aren’t allowed to own property, women who have no voting rights, no political say, their evidence is hardly admissible in court; and then these women aren’t even Roman citizens but Jews, making them even lower.  They have no strength, no weapons, and no standing.
Both the women and these burly guards experience the angel and the earthquake.  We are told the men are so terrified they shook and became like dead men.  Whereas we aren’t told how the women feel.  They are presumably afraid, but not as much as the men. 
The women hear the message and then they run to tell the disciples.  The women run one way.  What do the guards do?  They run the other way.  Verse 11 tells us that some of the guards go into the city and tell the chief priests.
The women’s message is that Jesus is alive and heading to Galilee, where it all began.  The guards message is that the dead guy they were guarding has escaped!  They probably left out the part that they were so terrified they shook while the women weren’t all that fussed.
On the way the women meet Jesus.  They lay hold of him and worship him.  Jesus also says not to be afraid but tell the disciples and keep going to Galilee.  The guards tell the chief priests who do what?
What did they do when Jesus was teaching in the temple compound?  They held a consultation.  What did they do when they had arrested Jesus?  They held a consultation.  What did they do when Judas returned the money?  They held a consultation. 
So what did they do here?  They held a consultation!  This Jesus fellow is certainly causing them a lot of headaches.  They would have loved to have Zoom to speed up all these consultations!
What did they do in their consultation?  Verse 12 tells us they “devised a plan.”  What did they do at all their previous consultations?  They made plans.
How much did they give Judas to betray Jesus?  You know the answer to this, 30 pieces of silver.  That’s the value of an injured slave according to Exodus.  An injured slave isn’t worth much.  Who would want one?  So Judas betrayed Jesus cheap!
Now what do these “consulting” and “planning” leaders do?  They offer a “large sum of money” to the soldiers.  We aren’t told how much.  But it is certainly hush money.  The religious leaders then tell the soldiers to lie: that they fell asleep and the disciples stole the body.  And, if the whole scheme catches up with them and they get into trouble with Pilate the governor, the religious leaders promise to keep them out of trouble.
Schemes, hush money, lies…  I could make a cheap crack about politicians but it would hardly be funny.  This is how the world works. 
We are just a few verses from the end of Matthew’s gospel.  And we are still strongly seeing a theme that Matthew has had from the beginning.  It is a contrast of kingdoms.  It is the kingdom of God vs. the kingdom of this world.  And the kingdom of this world includes: evil, the Roman government, the Jewish leadership, and the human point of view overall.
The human point of view, or the kingdom of this world, is all about protecting yourself, getting ahead, and staying alive.  It makes the human intellect supreme.  It warps facts to suit its needs.  And it insists that the logical human point of view must be God’s point of view.  In other words, it makes God into the human image. 
In the kingdom of God everything is reversed.  There we learn that humans are made in God’s image – not the other way around.  In the kingdom of God we learn that God’s sacrificial love is ultimate power, not self-preservation.  In the kingdom of God all are equal.  Things like money, looks, gender, brains, age make you neither higher nor lower than anyone else. 
Both kingdoms require hard work.  One leads to exploitation and a dead end, and an endless lack of satisfaction.  The other one, God’s kingdom leads to wholeness of life.
It seems to be an eternally ironic truth that the more you give of yourself – the more you use your power in support of others – the more fully you become your truest self.  Selfishness is the path to self-annihilation.  Self giving is the path to wholeness.
There are two more points to make about these verses.  First, our translation says that the soldiers took the money and did as they were directed.  It would be more literally translated that they took the money and did as they were taught.
Teaching is a key point for Matthew.  The Sermon on the Mount is not introduced as a sermon but as a teaching.  All throughout the gospel Jesus teaches.  At one point he sends his disciples out to spread the gospel and to heal and to cast out demons, but interestingly he does not give them permission to teach.  Next week we will discover that Jesus’ final sentence to his disciples is the commission to go out and teach.
It is only with the crucifixion behind them that they know enough to teach, and can now teach the truth.
But what about these soldiers, representing the kingdom of this world?  They are instructed by the religious leaders to teach lies – a lie that the body of Jesus was stolen by his disciples. 
            And that takes us to the final point.  Why did the women see the angel and the empty tomb and believe, yet the soldiers also saw the angel and the empty tomb and they did not believe? They both had the same evidence.  They both had the same experience.
            The resurrection is the key miracle of Christianity.  It is also the most controversial and hardest to believe.  It is just too counter to our experience for it to possibly be true.  Even the four gospels in the Bible struggle with it.  Jesus is resurrected, real flesh and blood.  He can be seen.  He can be touched.  He can eat.  In John’s gospel he even cooks breakfast.  But he can also come and go through locked doors.  He seems to appear and disappear without regard to the laws of physics.
            We’re going to look at doubt more next week.  But for this week we acknowledge that facts do not equal beliefs.
            Believing in Jesus, or maybe I should say orienting your life to be in God’s kingdom, does not come about by having the right facts and evidence.  You cannot make believers by facts.  Faith is not something we control.  Faith is not something a person comes to by analysis and conclusion.  Faith is God’s work.  It is God’s gift.
            We are not given an answer a to why the women believe and the soldiers do not.  Instead we are given the invitation to live the resurrection reality.  With that as our goal we can understand all of what Jesus did.  We can understand why the crucifixion is actually and expression of power.  We can see that God’s love does lead to restoration.  We can live without fear knowing that death is not the end.  It is not to be feared.  It too is within God’s grasp, and so we live knowing God’s triumph is ultimate.

No comments:

Post a Comment